Skip to content
Home » 4 Best Used Furniture Stores in Columbus, OH

4 Best Used Furniture Stores in Columbus, OH

  • by
Used Furniture Stores in Columbus OH

In Columbus, OH, shopping at used furniture stores means you can find furniture that’s not just old, but often almost new and in great quality. When someone in Columbus decides to sell their furniture, maybe because they’re moving or redecorating, that furniture can end up in a used furniture store. This means you might be buying pieces that are just a year or two old, have been well cared for, and are looking for a new home.

In 2022, Columbus managed to keep over 5,000 tons of furniture out of landfills by giving it a second chance in homes like yours. This is not just good for the planet; it’s also a chance for you to find stylish, high-quality furniture at a lower price. So, in Columbus, buying used furniture is a smart choice. It lets you upgrade your home with pieces that are both beautiful and affordable. Dive into the treasure hunt at Columbus’s used furniture stores and bring home items that are nearly new and full of quality.

1. One More Time Etc

One More Time Etc

Address:    1641 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212, United States
Phone:       +1 614-486-7571

One More Time Etc stands out as a gem for those in search of high-quality, gently used household treasures at reasonable prices. This locally owned and operated shop delights with its seamless buying and reselling process, friendly staff, and an ever-changing inventory of eclectic finds. Each visit promises a new discovery, from vintage items that tug at the heartstrings to unique pieces that add character to any space.

Beyond offering a diverse selection, One More Time Etc contributes to environmental sustainability by encouraging the reuse of goods. The fair pricing for both buyers and sellers, combined with excellent customer service, fosters a loyal community of regulars. This store not only prioritizes quality and diversity in its offerings but also champions a green approach to shopping, making it a must-visit for eco-conscious consumers and treasure hunters alike.

–> Services/Features

  • Ensuring a unique shopping experience with each visit.
  • An easy and efficient buying and reselling process.
  • Competitive pricing for both buyers and sellers.
  • Exceptional customer service from friendly and knowledgeable staff.
  • A commitment to environmental sustainability by promoting the reuse of goods.

2. Fresco Furnishings

Fresco Furnishings

Address:    1744 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212, United States
Phone:      +1 614-586-1963

Fresco Furnishings stands out as a consignment gem, offering a rich assortment of unique and quality items for the home. The store welcomes visitors with friendly staff, creating a warm shopping environment where everyone feels at home. Their innovative pricing strategy, which sees prices decrease over time, adds an element of excitement and affordability, allowing shoppers to snag great deals on distinctive finds.

Fresco Furnishings excels in both in-store and online shopping experiences, with quick shipping and excellent customer service, showcasing their commitment to customer satisfaction. This consignment store not only enriches homes with one-of-a-kind pieces but also cultivates a sense of community among its patrons, encouraging them to return often and discover new treasures. Fresco Furnishings embodies the ideal blend of quality, service, and value, making it a must-visit destination for those looking to enhance their living spaces.

–> Services/Features

  • The tiered pricing strategy rewards patience with potential savings on purchases.
  • A diverse and carefully curated selection of unique home furnishings and decorations.
  • Friendly and welcoming customer service both in-store and online.
  • Fast and reliable shipping for out-of-state purchases,
  • Ensuring items arrive quickly and undamaged.
  • Regular turnover of new and consigned items, inviting frequent visits to explore fresh finds.

3. Furniture with a Heart Thrift Store- Columbus

Furniture with a Heart Thrift Store- Columbus

Address:    2165 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH 43229, United States
Phone:       +1 614-826-4427

Furniture with a Heart Thrift Store in Columbus distinguishes itself not just as a store but as a community gem, offering a harmonious blend of quality, affordability, and exceptional service. The store prides itself on a wide array of furniture that caters to diverse tastes, from vintage beauties to modern pieces, all at astonishingly affordable prices. Staff members go above and beyond to assist customers, exemplified by their willingness to hold items and help with loading purchases.

The store’s cleanliness and organization enhance the shopping experience, making it a go-to destination for anyone looking to furnish their space without breaking the bank. While occasional issues arise, the store’s dedication to improving customer experience and its commitment to community support shine through, making it a valuable resource for both furniture seekers and those looking to contribute to a good cause.

–> Services/Features

  • Wide selection of quality, affordable furniture, including vintage and modern pieces.
  • Exceptional customer service, with staff members who are helpful and attentive.
  • Clean and well-organized store environment for a pleasant shopping experience.
  • Assistance with loading purchases and holding items for customer convenience.
  • Community support through donations and contributions to local causes.

4. All-American Furniture

All-American Furniture

Address:    635 Harrisburg Pike, Columbus, OH 43223, United States
Phone:        +1 614-444-4380

All-American Furniture stands out for its extensive collection of both new and used furnishings, including rare antiques and high-end items available through special catalogs. The store offers valuable layaway options, reflecting its commitment to accommodating customer needs. The owners frequently negotiate prices and ensure professional delivery services, showcasing their dedication to customer satisfaction. They regularly refresh their inventory, catering to those in search of unique vintage pieces.

However, the store has faced challenges, including incidents involving bed bugs in some items, and concerns over delivery charges and perceived overpricing have emerged. Despite these issues, the store’s emphasis on friendly and helpful customer service remains a strong point. All-American Furniture embodies the local furniture shop experience, offering a blend of unique finds and a community-centric approach, but it also highlights the importance of addressing quality control and pricing transparency to enhance customer trust and satisfaction.

–> Services/Features

  • A wide range of new and used furniture.
  • Layaway options to make purchases more accessible and financially manageable for customers.
  • Offering customers the opportunity to get better deals on their purchases.
  • Professional delivery services to ensure the safe and timely arrival of furniture to customers.
  • Regular updates to inventory, providing customers with fresh and diverse options to choose from.


Used furniture stores in Columbus, OH, are thriving as more people seek out affordable, sustainable options for their homes. These stores offer a diverse array of vintage, unique, and gently used pieces that cater to various tastes and budgets. By choosing second-hand, customers not only find one-of-a-kind items that add character to their living spaces but also contribute to environmental sustainability. Columbus’s vibrant market for used furniture, ranging from quaint local boutiques to expansive warehouses, has become a go-to destination for both avid collectors and those looking to furnish their homes with a touch of history and personality.