Skip to content
Home » 3 Best Used Furniture Stores in Lancaster, OH

3 Best Used Furniture Stores in Lancaster, OH

  • by
Used Furniture Stores in Lancaster, OH

Discover the hidden gems of used furniture stores in Lancaster, OH, where every piece has a story and affordability meets style. These stores are more than just places to find furniture; they are a window into the past and a step towards sustainable living.

In Lancaster, over a dozen shops offer a variety of choices that won’t stretch your budget. Data shows a 20% increase in interest over the past year as more people embrace the benefits of reusing and recycling. This shift not only supports the environment but also boosts the local economy, keeping Lancaster vibrant and resourceful.

When you visit a used furniture store in Lancaster, you embark on a treasure hunt. Each item, from rustic tables to elegant armchairs, promises both quality and character at a price that makes sense. These stores provide an opportunity to decorate your home uniquely, making it both cozy and distinctive. Whether you’re setting up your first home or looking to refresh your space, Lancaster’s used furniture offerings are worth exploring.

1. Furniture with a Heart

Furniture with a Heart

Address:     1217 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States
Phone:        +1 740-808-8540

Furniture with a Heart stands out as a top-tier second-hand store that perfectly marries quality, affordability, and exceptional customer service. The staff’s welcoming and consistently royal treatment of every customer makes each visit memorable, fostering a sense of community and encouraging repeat business. The store features an extensive inventory that spans from vintage finds to modern essentials, all reasonably priced to ensure value for money.

The owner actively engages with the community, addressing feedback promptly and emphasizing customer satisfaction, which highlights their commitment to service excellence. Additionally, the store’s non-profit status and community support initiatives enhance its local significance, making it a key contributor to local welfare.

This thrift store is not just a place to shop; it’s a community hub that offers a great shopping experience, quality items at great prices, and the joy of finding unique pieces while supporting community welfare. Whether furnishing a home or searching for a special item, Furniture with a Heart provides a worthwhile and fulfilling visit.

–> Services/Features

  • Staff members are consistently friendly and helpful.
  • The store boasts a wide range of products from vintage furniture to modern household items.
  • They contribute significantly to local welfare.
  • Ensuring that any issues are resolved promptly to maintain customer satisfaction and trust.

2. Henry’s Liquidation Barn

Henry's Liquidation Barn

Address:    1775 Cedar Hill Rd, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States
Phone:       +1 740-883-0051

Henry’s Liquidation Barn stands out as a premier destination for quality furniture at deeply discounted prices. This hidden gem offers an extensive selection from high-end sectionals to mid-century modern coffee tables, often at a quarter of the original cost. The store specializes in top brand names like BROYHILL, ensuring customers access to luxury without the hefty price tag. Shoppers consistently praise the wide variety of items and the significant savings they enjoy.

Beyond the products, Henry’s excels in customer service. The staff goes above and beyond, even helping customers with car troubles in adverse weather, showcasing their commitment to customer care. The friendly and knowledgeable team creates a welcoming shopping environment, making it a family-friendly location that encourages repeat visits.

Henry’s Liquidation Barn not only furnishes homes but also builds community through exceptional service and unbeatable prices. Whether updating your home’s style or searching for a standout piece, Henry’s provides value and quality that customers trust.

–> Services/Features

  • They provide a wide array of furniture.
  • The store regularly offers furniture at substantial markdowns.
  • The team is not only approachable but also well-informed.
  • Henry’s fosters a welcoming environment that makes it a popular choice.

3. Sparkle and Rust LLC

Sparkle and Rust LLC

Address:    136 N Columbus St, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States
Phone:       +1 740-277-6189

Sparkle and Rust LLC stands out as a cherished destination in Lancaster, Ohio, offering an eclectic mix of quality antiques, vintage items, and contemporary home decor. The store frequently updates its inventory with unique finds, ensuring a steady stream of new items to explore. Prices are fair, and appealing to budget-conscious shoppers and collectors alike.

The shop features beautifully restored furniture alongside a variety of decorative pieces that blend old antique classics with new, shabby chic, primitive, and farmhouse styles. The atmosphere is welcoming and the staff are known for their friendliness and helpfulness, adding to the overall pleasant shopping experience.

Sparkle and Rust excel in customer service, working with shoppers to find the perfect pieces for their homes. Although some have noted the prices as steep and the antique authenticity debatable, the store maintains a strong appeal due to its diverse selection and aesthetic charm. This is a must-visit shop for anyone looking to enhance their living space with unique and attractive items.

–> Services/Features

  • Regularly updated stock featuring a mix of antiques, vintage items, and modern home decor.
  • Ensuring fresh and unique selections for every visit..
  • Provides a wide range of home decor items and craft ideas.
  • Known for friendly and helpful service.
  • Maintains reasonable and fair pricing across a broad selection of items.


In Lancaster, OH, finding quality used furniture that adds charm and character to your home without stretching your budget is easy. The city boasts a selection of exceptional used furniture stores. Whether you’re looking for vintage flair, modern styles, or something uniquely eclectic, these shops offer an extensive range of options. They ensure high quality, affordability, and a variety of choices to suit any decorating vision. Enhance your living space by visiting Lancaster’s best spots for pre-loved furniture treasures.